Sony and ILM Heads Praise AI — But What About the Artists
At the VIEW Conference in Turin, seven heads of animation, VFX and visualization studios gathered on one stage to discuss generative AI, changing production pipelines and new lines of work. They spoke about technology willingly and at length. Asked what will happen to artists amid the layoffs, the panel answered noticeably more cautiously.
The discussion was moderated by Ian Failes, editor of befores & afters. At the table sat Janet Lewin, senior vice president and general manager of ILM; Michelle Grady, president of Sony Pictures Imageworks; Holly Edwards, president of Skydance Animation; Shawn Walsh, chief operating officer of Cinesite Group's VFX division and general manager of Image Engine; Ron Frankel, founder and head of Proof; Laurens Ehrmann, founder and creative director of The Yard; Henrik Fett, head of Opsis Studio.
AI compresses deadlines, but it can't compress taste
Walsh cautioned his colleagues against abruptly breaking established processes. "Abandoning an entire process for something with an unknown end point is not something that's easy to implement," he said, arguing for a gradual transition that preserves the creative intent and the control of the filmmakers. In his view, VFX artists will be needed for the foreseeable future, if only to manage that transition.
Lewin acknowledged the uncertainty of the technology: "There's a misconception about the magic bullet of AI and machine learning, and we just don't know how much these tools will change everything," she said, adding that keeping an open mind is nonetheless essential. Frankel takes a more applied view of generative models: for a visualization studio they speed up the creative exchange with the client. "The ability to have a creative conversation at the speed of ideas is a very powerful thing," he explained, noting that it hasn't got there yet.
Ehrmann put it more bluntly: "We talk about AI compressing execution time, but it can't compress taste." That is why, he said, the new generation of artists needs to be able to judge an image and improve it.
Real-time inside animated features
Grady described how Sony Pictures Imageworks uses Unreal Engine in its work with Sony Pictures Animation: the technology was first applied on "KPop Demon Hunters," then expanded on "Goat," and is now being pushed considerably further on "Spider-Man: Beyond the Spider-Verse." "It is wildly different from what we've done before," she said of the sequel. The film's directors prefer not to lock in decisions in advance and to experiment until the last minute, and the pipeline is built for that approach — around what Grady called "story camera, story acting and story lighting": artists try out these elements before entering full production. This, she said, involves more of the studio's artists in the creative part of production.
Lewin cited a figure that explains where the VFX business itself is shifting: traditional feature VFX today accounts for only about 40% of ILM's work, with the remaining 60% coming from other areas. The company is developing location-based entertainment, immersive formats and projects with digital avatars of musicians, and is also collaborating with Meta on immersive cinema. Edwards added that Skydance Animation is focused on the possibilities of the animated feature and CG production themselves, rather than on moving into adjacent businesses. Fett said his studio is working on a large-format touring concert installation, applying its visualization expertise to formats that engage the viewer differently than passive media.
Who actually decides how many jobs there will be
When the conversation turned to employment, the tone changed. "We don't exist without artists, period," Grady said, adding that the risk of studios disappearing is real: "If we don't figure out how to use the technology in a way that makes great images with great artists, then we've completely failed." Fett, speaking as the owner of an independent studio, called the well-being of his team a daily priority. Lewin stated the limits of her authority plainly: "Many of us are part of a parent company that makes decisions we can't influence." That includes which projects get greenlit, how much VFX they contain and what their budgets are — precisely the decisions that add up to the number of job openings. Specifics on exactly how the studios intend to preserve jobs were scarcer in the answers than acknowledgements of the importance of artists.
A separate part of the discussion concerned the geography of production incentives. Fett, whose studio works fully remotely and recruits senior artists worldwide, criticized the way tax incentives determine where a project is made: "I would love to take a magic wand and remove this whole incentives story." Frankel objected: productions go where the incentives are, these are state-level decisions, and all a contractor can do is be a local vendor within such an ecosystem — while the talent pool has to be assembled from those who live in the region.
What they advise those just entering the profession
The panel's advice came down to one thing: narrow specialization has stopped being a protection. Fett openly discouraged young artists from hyper-specialization — "learn your craft" — the toolbox should be full; he also noted that his remote studio relies on senior specialists, and mentoring newcomers is difficult. Grady formulated three principles — know your craft, find strong collaborators and stay flexible. Edwards also spoke about flexibility and about studios needing to provide training and the opportunity to move between departments. Frankel compared the arrival of AI to the invention of photography and the art movements that followed it, and hopes for a surge of new forms.
The practical takeaway for a professional: the odds are better for someone who understands several stages of the pipeline and can move from one department to another when the volume of work in their own drops off.
Why this conversation is happening now
The panel itself is a symptom of a larger process. Studio heads are publicly discussing artist employment against a backdrop of continuing layoffs, consolidation and a shrinking job market: in recent years the industry has been living in a mode of declining order volumes and production shifting between regions. Traditional centers are losing ground, while hubs with strong tax incentives are, conversely, attracting projects — that imbalance was discussed separately on the panel. Hence the emphasis on adaptability: it is a response not only to neural networks, but also to the shifting map of production.
It is also telling how the participants divided up responsibility. Service studios say they value artists, and at the same time remind us that budgets and greenlights are approved a level higher. That construction will likely keep reproducing itself: as long as decisions about how many projects to launch are made in parent corporations, the heads of production studios will remain in the role of those who explain the consequences rather than shape them.
If the trend holds, the nearest changes will affect team structure: fewer narrow roles, more hybrid specialists working across layout, animation and real-time assembly, and more projects beyond film — location-based entertainment, installations, immersive formats, which the panel discussed almost as much as features.
What lies behind studios' caution in hiring — the compression of deadlines under AI, decisions at the budget level, the overall drop in the number of greenlights?
Если студиям не будут нужны художники - зачем заказчику будут нужны студии? 🤷♂️
Абсолютно в дырочку ! )))
" меньше узких ролей, больше гибридных специалистов, работающих между лейаутом, анимацией и реалтайм-сборкой" - ммм прям мед... Но требований вы конечно снижать не будете) Напоминает анекдот про армию и фару на лоб.
Художник-режиссер google переводит как арт-директор. Вот такие дела. Уже можно сделать короткометражку "на коленке", а скоро - и метр. Один. Автор. Ну комадой веселее, а вот возможностей - уйма. Зачем тогда студии :-)